Who’s Your Daddy Now? by
(60 Stories)

Loading Share Buttons...

/ Stories

I guess I’m looking for signs that he’s my father, but he just looks like, seems like, acts like an ordinary man to me, any man.

1991. I’m 44, and on a whim I decide to contact my biological father. My mom had told me he lives up the coast in Ventura, so I figure I might as well start by looking him up in the phone book, and what do you know, there he is. I mean, who’s listed in the phone book any more?

“Hello, is this Bob?”

“Yes, this is Bob. Who is this?” A wary yet friendly voice.

“Well, this is going to come as a big surprise, but this is Barbara. I’m your daughter from your first marriage.”

“Well. That is a surprise.”

“I promise I don’t want anything. I just wanted to make contact, to let you know I’m out here, I live in L.A., and if you’d like to see me, I’d love to see you.”

“Well, now. Well, of course I’ll have to speak to my wife, Margaret. May I call you back?” He’s very formal.

He does call me back, and we set a date — my birthday, as it turns out — to meet halfway: lunch at Charley Brown’s Steakhouse in Thousand Oaks.


Coming in from the bright sunlight, it takes a while for my eyes to adjust. I scan the large dining room. Maybe that’s him, sitting at a four-top with a woman, and as I walk towards them, he sees me and stands up. We’re all smiles, we hug, the woman stands up, he introduces her as his wife, Margaret, we hug, and then we all sit down. It’s a bit awkward getting started, but soon the waitress swoops over and my father tells her this is a celebration and explains that I’m his daughter and we haven’t seen each other in forty plus years, and it’s my birthday, and she gets excited and calls another waitress over and the next thing you know we’re all drinking champagne and toasting.

It’s not what you’d call a reunion, because we don’t really even know each other — my mom left him when I was just six months old and I haven’t seen him since — but we start chipping away to catch up. Of course I tell him about my brother Larry — his son — and yes, he knew about his death at just 23 but, oddly, doesn’t seem particularly interested in learning any more about him, or about my mother. I don’t know, I guess I’m looking for signs that he’s my father, but he just looks like, seems like, acts like an ordinary man to me, any man. But we’re good, at least we like each other so far, and by the time he picks up the tab, we know we want to see each other again.


Over time I meet my four half siblings. They didn’t know about his first marriage, and of course they’re suspicious of my motives. Why wouldn’t they be? Just as I assured him, I assure them I don’t want anything, and I don’t, at least not monetarily. What I do want is to nurture the bond with this man that is my real father, this quiet, sober, ordinary man, a photographer who also crafts wooden bowls in his woodshop, the man from whom I inherited much of what I now recognize as the genes of creativity.

We stay in regular touch — not close touch, but close enough for me — and I bring my daughter for a visit once or twice. I always refer to him as “Bob.”

# # #

Years pass and I’m still seeing my bio dad, Bob, driving up to Ventura at least once a month now, often spending the night in my half-sister Terry’s old bedroom. Margaret has passed on, his kids live out of state, and he’s lonely, although he’s in good health and still regularly plays 18 holes with his pals. I’ve begun bringing him to family events and one Easter he and my mom — his ex-wife — even held hands for a bit. She was interested but he wasn’t, and that was that.

Somewhere along the line I begin calling him Dad instead of Bob, and I begin referring to the man I grew up with, the man I used to call Daddy, as Earl. (The alcoholism finally caught up with Earl, and he died in 1979.) Now I finally have a dad that feels like a dad, a dad that believes in me. New and improved Dad is very supportive — he wants to make up for not having been there when I was a child. He listens and gives me advice on my business ventures. He offers me the money to buy a nice used car when my old one finally conks out, says it gives him great pleasure to be able to help and that it’s the very least he can do for me. He may have a point there, and I graciously accept his generosity. We have so much in common: creativity, bookishness, quietness, genes.

I always look forward to seeing Dad. We usually go to The Sportsman steak house for dinner, settle into one of the red leather booths for a cozy chat, and we each enjoy a dry gin martini, straight up, with olives. Then we go back to his house, get comfortable, and watch a movie. I eventually doze off on the sofa, then trudge half asleep down the hallway and fall into Terry’s childhood bed.

This one time I arrive and he, natty in a sports coat and trousers, has a martini waiting for me. He prides himself on his dry martinis — he uses a tiny spritzer to barely mist an icy frosted glass with vermouth, then adds Bombay Sapphire gin and two stuffed green olives. We sip and chitchat, me sitting on the sofa, he in an easy chair across from me. Our reservation at The Sportsman isn’t for another hour.

“Dear,” he says. I’m still fond of his formal, old-fashioned manner of speaking. “I have something to confess.”

“Uh-oh…what’s the matter, Dad?” Confess? He was a devout Catholic but stopped going to church after Margaret died.

“Dear, you know how much I look forward to your visits,” he says. “I’ve been terribly lonely since Margaret died. You’ve made my life bearable, and I love you so very much.”

“Aw, thanks, Dad…I love you, too! But what’s going on?”

“To be honest…goodness, I really don’t quite know how to say this,” he says. “I can’t stop thinking about you.” And then, “ I’m afraid I’ve fallen in love with you.”

“Well, that’s a problem,” I say. Talk about an understatement.

“I know it is, I know it is,” he says. “But I don’t know what to do about it. I think of you as a woman, not as my daughter.” As he speaks, he stands and moves to the sofa, then sits down next to me, too close.

“Well, there’s nothing to do about it. Just put it out of your mind. It’s inappropriate, Dad, and that’s all there is to it,” I say. “I am your daughter, for God’s sake!”

“Yes, of course, of course — his eyes are filling with tears.

“Oh, Dad, I’m sorry, I’m not mad, it’s not your fault. Shit. I’ll talk to you later, okay?” and I grab my bags and run out the front door.

I am angry, and confused, and panicked, Had I given him the wrong idea? I continue to visit Bob for the rest of his life, but I never go back alone.

I had given Earl short shrift. My mom was right when she’d dropped that bombshell so many years ago, then added: “Your Daddy treated you exactly the same way he treated your brothers. No one would ever have thought he wasn’t your real father.” He wasn’t my birth father, but he was my real father. He was also complicated, our relationship was complicated, and we never got to sort things out. Talk about regrets . . . I’ve had a few.

Profile photo of Barbara Buckles Barbara Buckles
Artist, writer, storyteller, spy. Okay, not a spy…I was just going for the rhythm.

I call myself “an inveterate dabbler.” (And my husband calls me “an invertebrate babbler.”) I just love to create one way or another. My latest passion is telling true stories live, on stage. Because it scares the hell out of me.

As a memoirist, I focus on the undercurrents. Drawing from memory, diaries, notes, letters and photographs, I never ever lie, but I do claim creative license when fleshing out actual events in order to enhance the literary quality, i.e., what I might have been wearing, what might have been on the table, what season it might have been. By virtue of its genre, memoir also adds a patina of introspection and insight that most probably did not exist in real time.

Visit Author's Website

Tags: father, biological father, bio dad


  1. Marian says:

    Wow, what complexity here, Barbara. I guess tracking someone down comes with multilayered joys and regrets. I hope you find balance in this relationship.

  2. Betsy Pfau says:

    Quite a story there, Barbara. You’ve shared part of it with us before, but that last part (I’m in love with you) is a real bombshell! That must have really thrown you for a loop. It is true that Bob didn’t know you as a child, so had no notion of you as a little girl, but wow, really creepy. Glad you kept your cool, kept seeing him, but never alone. Very complicated situation.

    • Thanks, Betsy. I keep reminding myself that since he hadn’t known me as a child, it wasn’t THAT creepy, more inappropriate than anything. And it was such a let down to hear that from the man I looked to as an example of how a father, and a man, should and could be . Now I look to my husband. I finally put my faith in the right person.

  3. Oh Barbara, brava to you for handling the challenging situation so well.
    Your story makes me think of 2 films about the search for family truths that were at theatres a few years ago:
    LITTLE WHITE LIE -(not the current film with similar title) about a bi-racial girl raised in a white family
    THREE IDENTICAL STRANGERS – about triplets separated at birth
    If you haven’t seen them, hope you can track them down!

    • Thanks so much, Dana! I did see both those films. Also, “Stories We Tell” and the book “Inheritance” by Dani Shapiro both have similar overtones. Actually, there are quite a few films and memoirs on the subject of discovering one of your parents (usually the father) is not your biological parent and how it affects your life. What’s most interesting to me is how often the person had a sense that something was “off” and the revelation came as a huge relief.

  4. Suzy says:

    Barbara, thanks for giving us this last piece of the story we have been learning from you gradually over several prompts. Great that you were able to find your bio-dad, and it wasn’t even difficult (in the phone book? too easy!). It sounds like it went well for a while. Good thing you kept your wits about you when things got weird. And that you were able to sort out your feelings about Bob and Earl and who was the real father. Looking forward to more stories from you on all kinds of topics.

  5. Laurie Levy says:

    Barbara, I am at a loss for words after reading this. You were let down by both of your fathers. I’m glad you found and got to know your bio dad so you can see where some of who you are came from. And I suppose you formed a meaningful relationship and can attribute his inappropriate feelings to age and loneliness. After dealing with your step-father’s alcoholism all of your life and finding out that he was not your birth father, it was important to track down the man who was your birth father. Hope that connection brought you some closure.

    • Laurie, thanks for your understanding. For me the bottom line is that writing about it all when I decided to tackle a memoir a few years ago helped me unravel my confusion and brought peace of mind. For too many years I acted out and blamed myself for making poor decisions and choices, fearing I was a train wreck and not understanding why. Writing is a wonderful way to process our experiences in a creative way. Now it’s just fun to write.

  6. Laurie has it right: a complete loss for words. Thankfully you’re not. A hard story wonderfully told.

  7. A terribly beautiful story, Barbara. So struck and moved by the revelation of father/daughter collision. You foreshadowed it beautifully, btw. Thanks for delivering the full monty so courageously.

Leave a Reply