Who’s Your Daddy? by
(47 Stories)

Prompted By Surprise!

Loading Share Buttons...

/ Stories

It’s 1976. I’m 30. My mother looks me in the eye for a few long seconds, pressing her lips together, an odd expression on her face. She leans forward. “What if I told you that you were adopted?”

I have the distinct impression of brightening light, as if the sun has just moved out from behind a cloud.

It’s Friday, and we’re having lunch at the Hamburger Hamlet on Hollywood Boulevard, the one right off La Brea. In high heels and a skirt suit with a low-cut blouse, she’s on her lunch break. She’s the head of the children’s department at a talent agency across the street. In flip-flops, faded blue jeans and a sweatshirt, I’ve come across town from a session with my shrink.

“I wouldn’t believe you,” I pretty much snort, leaning back and crossing my arms in front of me. “I know you’re my mom.” Our resemblance, in both appearance and mannerism, is unmistakable. Even now, we both sit with our legs crossed at the knee, one ankle hooked behind the other.

A pause. “Well, sure, honey, I’m your mom, but,” another pause, “Daddy isn’t your real father.”

I stare at her as the words begin to sink in. I have the distinct impression of brightening light, as if the sun has just moved out from behind a cloud.

We’re sitting across the table from each other. To anyone else we’re just two women having lunch. Although there might have been a subtle change in our body language, there’s no crying or shouting, no gesturing to betray the immensity of her revelation. But all around me, thought bubbles explode. No wonder . . . No wonder . . . No wonder . . . And then ah, so that explains everything . . . the unspoken guilt I’d always assumed for not feeling like “daddy’s little girl.” The time my big brother tauntingly whispered that I was adopted. The “fact” that all my baby photos had vanished in a flood. And the very real fact that my earliest memories were of people who weren’t my parents.

Right before her revelation, I’d just told my mom about the very odd feeling I’d experienced while talking to Bette, the psychologist I met with weekly in an effort to get to the bottom of my anxiety. Confiding to the shrink about an argument I’d had with my dad earlier that day, tears had streamed down my face yet I felt absolutely no emotion. The disconnect was so absolute and, to me, inexplicable that I had impulsively shared the experience with my mom.

“Your Daddy treated you exactly the same as he treated your brothers. No one would ever have thought that he wasn’t your real father.”

She‘s probably right about that, but without really thinking about it I’d known something was missing. I thought it was me, something missing in me, something wrong with me for not loving him. Relief swept over me like a gentle breeze. It wasn’t my fault. Maybe he didn’t love me, or maybe he’d held back affection because I wasn’t “his,” because maybe he felt awkward, or even resentful. And suddenly I felt a surge of love for him, because now he was just a man, a man who had taken good care of me.

I had so many questions I didn’t know where to start.

“Well, who is my father?” I asked.

“His name is Bob, Robert. He remarried right after we divorced, moved to Ventura, and had four children of his own.”

“You divorced him? Why?”

“Because Daddy and I fell in love.”

I asked her why she hadn’t told me before.

“You’ve always been so sensitive,” she said. “We had no way of knowing how you would react.”

Before I can ask another question she said, “Tell you what, sweetie, Gaga has some things stored in her closet, photos and papers and whatnot. Let’s pull everything out tomorrow and I’ll tell you the whole story. I’ve got to get back to work.”

I persisted. “Ventura? Does he still live there?” That’s less than an hour’s drive from L.A.!

“Yeah, he does,” she said, motioning for the check, “but it would really be best — for everyone — if you didn’t try to contact him.”

“Why not?” I asked.

“Well, his wife is Catholic . . . it’s just complicated, Barb. His kids may not even know about you. But let’s not rock the boat. Why would you want to make waves,” she said. It wasn’t really a question.

She knew me. I didn’t want to make waves, and I wouldn’t . . . at least not for another ten years.

Profile photo of Barbara Buckles Barbara Buckles
Artist, writer, storyteller, spy. Okay, not a spy…I was just going for the rhythm.

I call myself “an inveterate dabbler.” (And my husband calls me “an invertebrate babbler.”) I just love to create one way or another. My latest passion is telling true stories live, on stage. Because it scares the hell out of me.

As a memoirist, I focus on the undercurrents. Drawing from memory, diaries, notes, letters and photographs, I never ever lie, but I do claim creative license when fleshing out actual events in order to enhance the literary quality, i.e., what I might have been wearing, what might have been on the table, what season it might have been. By virtue of its genre, memoir also adds a patina of introspection and insight that most probably did not exist in real time.

Visit Author's Website

Tags: adoption, secrets, family,
Characterizations: moving, well written


  1. Laurie Levy says:

    Wow, Barbara, that’s a major surprise. It must have been a huge shock to learn about this at age 30, even though clearly you had an inkling something wasn’t right all of your life. I know from other adoptees that these secrets inevitably come out, so it is probably best not to have secrets to begin with. As usual, you leave me wanting to know more. You are a great story teller and I want to read the 10-year-later sequel someday.

    • Oh, Laurie, you’re so right! Kids have a way of knowing something’s off, even if they can’t articulate it. I’m amazed at how many stories I’ve read or heard where people have the same experience I had, that feeling of a-ha! And then of course there are those who are blind-sided (Dani Shapiro comes to mind — and her book “Inheritance” is worth a read). I guess there can be extenuating circumstances, but I think most people benefit from the truth. Thanks so much for the praise…and don’t touch that dial!

  2. Betsy Pfau says:

    Wow, that is quite a bombshell to drop on you, Barbara! Did you ever get to meet your biological father? Did it help you process your feelings any better? Did seeing the photos help you? Thanks for sharing this story, it’s really something.

  3. Suzy says:

    Wow, now I see why you suggested this prompt. And also the prompt Tracking People Down, when you will presumably write the next chapter. I hope you will also tie in Aunt Blanche and Uncle Ernie at some point. This surely has the makings of a fabulous movie!

    Thank you so much for this breathtaking and beautifully written surprise story!

    • Wow back, Suzy, thanks SO much!! I’m touched that you remember Aunt Blanche and Uncle Ernie and soon (as in next week) you’ll see how they play into all this. And by the time Tracking People Down drops, you’ll have the framework for the whole story. I sure appreciate your interest!

  4. Oh dear Barbara, fact is often stranger than fiction and as dramatic. .
    By chance I just saw a documentary called Little White Lie with a similar tale to tell.
    I hope you came out with resilience and resolution! ❤️

  5. John Shutkin says:

    Talk about great minds thinking alike, “Wow!” was the first word that came to my mind and, scanning down the comments, that was obviously the case for other readers. (What should we call ourselves? How about “Retrogrades”?) And a beautifully told story about an amazing surprise. Though, as you note, a lot of it fit together in, ahem, retrospect. You have even inspired me to think of a similar, but hardly as traumatic, surprise in my own life. Thanks!

    • Hmmm, not sure about “retrogrades,” John…I like that it makes us sound a little like renegades, rebels that we are…or were! On the other hand, it also makes us sound like we’re moving backwards, which of course we aren’t! Eager to hear about your own surprise!

  6. Surprise, indeed! I think the ‘stigma’ attached to divorce has lessened greatly, at least in some subcultures. I’m guessing you were in your late teens or early ’20s when your mother made that revelation. I was intrigued by your description of the confusion you felt about your father. So many signals to sort out there. He may have felt his own confusion, however well he cared for you. I do look forward to reading the sequel, should the occasion arise. Great storytelling, Barbara!

    • Thanks so much, Charles. I was 30 when I got the surprise of my life. It’s a challenge to tell such a personal story in a way that others can relate to, and I’m so glad you picked up on the confusion aspect, both on my part and my dad’s. There are so many layers that play into it, hence I keep returning to the story to flesh it out. Very few things in life are black or white, and it’s those gray areas that intrigue me. As you may have already discovered, the sequel — or I guess I should say the prequel — dropped today for the “Baby Books” prompt, a prompt which I’ll be interested in seeing how many men respond to with stories of their own!

Leave a Reply