Be True to Your School by
(303 Stories)

Prompted By Middle School

Loading Share Buttons...

/ Stories

Part of 7th grade class picture. I’m in the middle, in dark sweater and skirt.

Middle School. . . . In our day they called it Junior High School. I don’t know when the name was changed, or why, but in any event, I never went to one. My first school was a K-8, and my second school was a 7-12.

My town didn’t have a Junior High at that time. The elementary schools, of which there were nine, all went from kindergarten through 8th grade. My school was named Number Three School, because it had been the third one built. My older sisters went to Number Three, and then on to Belleville High School, the one and only high school in our town. While they were there, the quality of the high school plummeted. It was overcrowded, and eventually lost its accreditation. It also had more than its share of juvenile delinquents, or “hoods” as we called them. These hoods were of both genders. My middle sister once had a switchblade pulled on her in the girls’ bathroom. My parents, at the urging of my sisters, decided not to send me there.

So in sixth grade I took the admission test for a selective public high school called College High School, in Upper Montclair, a very WASPy town about 10 miles, and a cultural lifetime, away from my town. It was a six-year high school, going from seventh grade through twelfth. After passing a written test and an interview, I was admitted.

At Number Three School, I had been pretty popular. I had a friend group, and even a sort-of boyfriend. We had all known each other for years. I was sad to leave them all at the end of sixth grade. I was also mad that I got gypped out of a graduation, since that wouldn’t happen til eighth grade and I wouldn’t be there then. But I knew going to College High was the right thing to do, or maybe — come to think of it — I was never given a choice in the matter.

At College High, all the seventh graders were new, and they came from several different towns in the area. As a result, most were in the same boat I was, not knowing anyone before they got there. But there was a core group of about 6 or 7 from Montclair and Upper Montclair who did know each other, and it must have been a lot easier for them. Some, but not all. of these Montclair kids became the core of the popular crowd.

Everyone was friendly initially, as far as I can remember. But my town was very far behind Montclair in sophistication, and as a result so was I. As you can see from the portion of the class picture that I have used for the Featured Image, I am wearing white bobby socks, while most of the girls in the class were already wearing stockings, or at least knee socks like the girls on either side of me in the picture.

Also, because I had skipped a grade, and my birthday is at the end of August, I had turned eleven less than a week before I started 7th grade. Everyone else was twelve, some were almost thirteen. That is a huge developmental gap at that age. I was fine academically, but socially it took me a while to catch up even enough to understand what people were talking about.

And then, the problem at such a small school (only thirty-one of us in the class, sixteen girls and fifteen boys) was that the impression you made at the beginning tended to stick with you for the entire six years. There were a couple of exceptions, girls who started out mousy and unpopular who later became school royalty. But this generally involved winning the genetic lottery and developing large breasts, plus having straight hair and a complexion that worked with bleaching it platinum blonde. I had none of these attributes, so as hard as I tried to get into the popular crowd, I was doomed.

I don’t think of any of them as mean girls, like the ones in the movie of the same name. The popular girls were never mean to me. In fact, in one-on-one conversations, they were very friendly and nice. I would often talk on the phone with one or another of them, or hang out together sometimes. It was just when they all got together, there wasn’t room for me.

Actually I suffered more from being ignored by the boys. I went to all the school dances, and kept hoping that someone would ask me to dance, but nobody ever did. So I danced the fast dances with other girls, and then went back to the wall (yes, a veritable wallflower) during the slow ones. I don’t know why I didn’t stop going, but I guess I kept hoping that magically things would change.

I wore glasses (although never in pictures), and got braces during seventh grade, which didn’t help matters. When the braces came off in the middle of ninth grade, that actually was a magical change. A couple of boys in older classes started noticing me and my radiant smile, but by that time it was too late to affect the opinion of boys in my own class.

The Beach Boys song “Be True to Your School” came out in October 1963, the fall of my 8th grade year. The principal made the DJs play it over and over at school dances, to emphasize the importance of school spirit. One thing everyone could agree on was how sick we got of that song! I like it now, but it always reminds me of those painful College High dances.

To complete the story, here I am in my eighth grade class picture. I had moved on from headbands to hairbows. I have the closed-mouth smile of a braces wearer. Now I can see that I was kind of cute, but I sure didn’t think so then! It took me until college to become confident in myself socially, because College High, starting in seventh grade, had convinced me that I was undesirable.


# # #

Profile photo of Suzy Suzy

Characterizations: well written


  1. John Shutkin says:

    You have encapsulated the whole “middle school” experience, and all of its discomforts, perfectly. (I put “middle school” in quotes because, like you, we called it “junior high school,” and I have yet to buy into the euphemism that you were somewhere in the middle; you were at the bottom.) Of course, the anxieties were a bit different with boys, but they were certainly analogous, so you have captured the whole experience for both genders.

    But you have added to your story the additional level of adolescent angst of coming in from another school (though this was more the rule than the exception, it would seem). And not only that, but coming from a less sophisticated school background. And being younger than most of your classmates. All of these are surmountable issues, and you certainly surmounted them (and how!), but it is most interesting that you didn’t really feel self-confident until you were in college. It reminds me that, as perfect as your title is, Paul Simon’s “Kodachrome,,” and its derisive take on high school, might have also applied — at least to your, ahem, “middle school” years.

    • Suzy says:

      Thanks John. You are right about it not being the middle, although ironically if I had stayed at No. 3 School, in 7th and 8th grade I would have been at the top. Instead I was at the bottom of the six-year heap at College High.

      I don’t think “Kodachrome” applies, because I didn’t learn “crap” in high school, I got a fabulous education, and it’s not “a wonder I can think at all.” Today in the car I heard “Wishin’ and Hopin'” by Dusty Springfield, and thought that would have been a good choice, since that was how I approached the school dances.

      • John Shutkin says:

        Absolutely delighted to defer to your choice of high school songs. Not only are you obviously in a better position to know, but glad it was not the cynical experience reflected in “Kodachrome.” And certainly better than the character in “A Chorus Line,” who, in recounting his miserable childhood in NYC, said (or maybe sang) that he had attended “P. S. Sh*t.”

  2. Such a sad and friendly recollection of those days and the painful transition from school to school. I enjoyed your socioeconomic analysis of the differences between schools, the deterioration of Belleville High School, clearly named so by Rod Serling for an episode of Twilight Zone. The lag between bobby sox and stockings, your retro realization that you didn’t have much choice about school. Sisters threatened with switchblades, the cliques forming out of the original friendliness, all the growing pains you describe so clearly and warmly. You rang many familiar bells with this story. Tks!

  3. Betsy Pfau says:

    Suzy, I think you encapsulate a lot of what we youngsters felt who were younger and less sophisticated than those in our peer group. Also, braces and glasses were the bane of that age group for many of us. Unlike you, I was tiny, not tall, but still out of place and out of my depth at everything socially, so I really related to this story. But we all grew up and blossomed and found our place in the world. Thanks for sharing your experiences.

    • Suzy says:

      Yes, it was a tough time for most of us. I would love to read a story about someone who actually enjoyed junior high. Wonder if it has ever been written – or if anyone here on Retrospect has good memories they can write about.

  4. John Zussman says:

    It is the tragedy of middle school that kids as cute and smart as you clearly were become convinced they are undesirable. From the other side, even though boys had the privilege of asking girls to dance, it took superhuman effort to put one’s ego on the line and actually do so, so we were almost as likely to end up adorning the wall. (More on this in a couple of weeks.) I’m glad things changed for the better when your braces came off.

    • Suzy says:

      Things were slightly better after the braces came off, but only briefly. It wasn’t until I got to Cambridge that things really changed. There I felt like the ugly duckling who had just turned into a swan.

  5. I enjoyed your story. And Cambridge educated now? Blessed, lovely Swan! Looking back is revelatory, and helps others who read about all of your memories and experiences (to not feel so alone), but goodness, look where you are, who you are, where you’ve been. . . I’ve never understood how pretty girls like yourself could feel “undesirable” or like “an ugly duckling”. . . really? What kind of foggy spectacles were you looking through, child? Thanks for sharing so openly; it was an enjoyable read.

Leave a Reply