Which Club Should I Join? by
(11 Stories)

Prompted By Faith

Loading Share Buttons...

/ Stories

It seems to me I was raised Protestant. At least those were the Sunday schools I attended. My Dad was raised Catholic -as in most Latino families- but never spoke of it. He scoffed a little at my Mom who loved to dress up my brother and I and walk to church. One of my favorite books, shared with my own kids, was The Bible in Pictures. Kind of a graphic novel in black and white, interspersed with beautiful paintings of the celebratory Jesus Entering Jerusalem or the pathos of Jesus on the Cross. Memorable stuff.

It felt like every one was recruiting me...

A particular honor of Sunday school was to be invited to participate in the Christmas Pageant. One year I was honored to dress up in real shepherd clothes, carry a real jeweled knife from Israel, and stand by the manger gazing at the Baby Jesus. But as I was reminded for many years afterwards, I didn’t actually stand. I fidgeted, hopping from one leg to another like any normal seven year old.

When I reached college, with history as one of my favorite subjects, I was exposed to far more than the suburban version of Christianity. And disappointment and disillusion set in. Too many people died in the name of God, too many televangelists were getting rich, and too many similarities existed between religions to justify me selecting just one to join. It felt like every one was recruiting me with promises of, “our club is the best, here’s the initiation requirements, and you’ll get these special benefits that none of the others allow.”

By now I’ve come to realize the absolute need to have spirituality in our lives, to help us understand our relationship to the world and each other. I’ve become very familiar with the history of all the worlds’ great religions, and I say my prayers every night as I have since Sunday school. And so my relationship with God is uniquely my own.


Profile photo of Mike Sanchez mike7353

Characterizations: been there, right on!


  1. Betsy Pfau says:

    Thank you for sharing your own story. We all have them, don’t we? I particularly like the way you state that your relationship with God is uniquely your own…as it should be!

  2. John Zussman says:

    This is very similar to the path I took: wonder and awe as a child, eroding as we matured to realize the two-edged role that organized religion has played in world history. It’s a tribute that you found a way to leave the church without abandoning God. Thanks for sharing.

  3. Susan says:

    Mike, I am so struck by your observation about recruiting by churches. Replace “evangelize” with “marketing” and look out, let the cynicism flow! I too was raised Protestant, and I recall year after year of sunday school consisting of ever-deeper entrenching of the smug messages about why we were the best, and what exactly we got that those unsuspecting and unenlightened “others” wouldn’t receive. I agree with John, bravo to you for keeping your eyes on the spirituality prize without getting bogged down in the marketing hype!

Leave a Reply